Wednesday, October 27, 2021
HomeInterviewsPaul Kimmage in 2006 - "Stop treating people like me as pariahs"

Paul Kimmage in 2006 – “Stop treating people like me as pariahs”

-

Paul Kimmage
Paul also writes about other sports, and his book “Engage” won last year’s William Hill Irish Sports Book of the Year.

Paul Kimmage has been a near-lone voice in the wilderness for a long time, questioning the ethics in cycling and railing against the alleged corruption amongst the riders and the people charged with running the sport for over 20 years.

And yet he is the person whom the UCI, their President Pat McQuaid and ex-President Hein Verbruggen are suing in the Swiss Courts in a couple of months time, for saying out loud what we’ve all been thinking, and for writing articles in the Sunday Independent and later for the Sunday Times, as well as on sites such as NYVeloCity.com, where he published the entire transcript of his interview with FLoyd Landis early in 2011.

Kimmage has consistently accused McQuaid and Verbruggen of “having knowingly tolerated tests, of being dishonest people, of not having a sense of responsibility, of not applying the same rules to everyone.”, and the theory goes that the UCI are suing him (and not the papers his words appeared in) because he is a relatively easy target (being unemployed since earlier in the year) in order to send a message to the rest of their critics that speaking out publicly against them may prove to be more costly in terms of money and time than it’s worth.

But their plan appears to be back-firing mightily.

Five days ago a fund was setup for Kimmage by the guys at NYVeloCity.com and  Cyclismas.com where anyone can offer their support by donating some money – and it’s currently running at over $33,000.

The initial idea of the fund was to provide Kimmage with help towards his legal expenses but what’s actually happened is that it’s become a focus for change, for fans of cycling who want to help get the sport back onto an even keel again, and many see getting rid of the (for now allegedly) corrupt old-schoolers as an essential step.

The fund still has two months to run (it closes on December 1st) and it’s not beyond the realms of possibility that Kimmage could have enough money behind him to bring a counter-suit.

Either way, the court case and the necessary funds will surely give Kimmage an opportunity to substantiate his claims with enough witness testimony to satisfy Swiss law.  As InnerRing puts it:

“Here’s the concise definition of defamation under the Swiss Criminal Code:

” ‘Any person who in addressing a third party, makes an accusation against or casts suspicion on another of dishonourable conduct or of other conduct that is liable to damage another’s reputation.’

“We could joke that Verbruggen and McQuaid’s reputation is so low that Kimmage didn’t do any additional harm but that’s subjective. Let’s stick to the law as the Code goes on to explain something that seems crucial for Kimmage’s defence:

” ‘If the accused proves… … he had substantial grounds to hold an honest belief that it was true, he may not be held guilty of an offence.’ “

Pat McQuaid may well come to regret some of his decisions.

Judging by the content of Tyler Hamilton’s book “The Secret Race” and the fact that USADA Director Travis Tygart stated the other day in an interview with Cyclingnews.com that USADA have compiled a body of evidence in the ‘USPS Conspiracy’ case 30 times more damning than what’s been seen in the public domain already, it’s reasonable to assume that Kimmage has the potential to make McQuaid and Verbruggen deeply regret bringing him to an open court.

Referring to another suit that the UCI (or it’s leadership) had brought against Floyd Landis last year, McQuaid told Cyclingnews Editor Daniel Benson;

“I will not accept anyone saying that I or the UCI is corrupt. If you say that about the UCI, that’s 90 people affected. I will not accept that the UCI is corrupt or has ever been corrupt. I just will not accept that. If someone wants to say that, they need to stand up and show the proof.”

This may just be the time for Paul Kimmage to be that someone, to provide a Swiss Court, lovers and followers of cycling, and the watching world at large, that proof.

In light of this, we thought it would be interesting to revisit a couple of interviews with Kimmage, to see if his position and message have changed any in the interim.

The first interview, reprised below, dates back five years and in it Kimmage talks about what he thought as he watched Floyd Landis take a hammering in the Tour then go on to take the Maillot Jaune, and ultimately become yet another huge disappointment when he tested positive and was stripped of the win.

Contribute at Chipin (uses PayPal) to the Paul Kimmage Fund


First published August 2006

One of the most famous names in the anti-dope crusade is ex-pro Paul Kimmage, who’s 1990 book ‘Rough Ride’, a ground-breaking book detailing his years as a domestique in the professional ranks from 1986 to 1989 was one of the first to blatantly expose doping in pro cycling.

Now a successful journalist with the Sunday Times of London, VeloVeritas was curious to hear his thoughts about the Landis affair.

Paul’s book was the candid story of a young Irishman’s journey from raw, green amateur to disillusioned, cynical ex-pro.

Paul Kimmage
Rather than the usual ‘Boys Own’ comic stuff it dipped into the murky world of damaged individuals and proscribed substances.

In those pre-ProTour days, ‘omerta’ ruled; the Sicilian code of silence – the author had ‘spat in the soup’ with his revelations about his own drug-taking that was instrumental in his quitting the sport.

Paul Kimmage has remained a thorn in the side of those who would rather we didn’t talk about drugs; he’s the guy who pops-up with the awkward question at exactly the wrong moment.

Thanks for taking the time to talk to us Paul. As a pro you were well on the ladder to better things, any regrets about not going as far as you could have?

“None, I’m very happy with how my career has gone since I quit as a pro.

“I have no bitterness and I regard it as an enriching part of the school of life.

“Maybe if I hadn’t had a successful career as a journalist I would feel different.”

Paul Kimmage
Paul relaxes in the Village Depart in happier times.

What were your thoughts when the Operacion Puerto storm broke just before the Tour started?

“I was thrilled.

“I watched the Giro and was appalled at what I saw, riders going up huge climbs like robots, with ease.

“Look at old videos of Greg Lemond and Laurent Fignon in the Tour; you won’t see them climbing like that.

“It’s not recognisable as the same sport I participated in.”

Do you think that the success of the French riders in the Tour was due to a more level playing field with the Puerto exclusions and fears scandal?

“There’s no doubt about that.

“Initially I was very hopeful about this Tour, especially when I saw Landis crack on stage 16. I thought – well, he’s human, he’s taken a bloody good hiding, there’s good days and bad days and that was a bad one.

“It helped rekindle my enthusiasm for the Tour. However the non-performance of some favourites – we all know who they are – speaks for itself.

“The French teams have had a hard time of it with journalists writing about the riders being lazy – not doing the training or not looking after themselves.”

[editor. Note – it is generally acknowledged that the French Government’s ‘linear health checks’ on professional riders are very stringent]

Paul Kimmage
Landis and Pereiro share at joke at the Tour, perhaps about those pesky needle bruises.

What’s your take on Landis’s initial line of defence?

“How many times have we heard it all before; how do they say it with a straight face?

“I saw his first tele-cast to a couple of American journalists, he was shaken and subdued.

“The next day he’s in Madrid with his high-powered lawyers telling us the way he’s being treated is outrageous.

“When he took the jersey for the first time, I wrote in the Sunday Times that I hoped his performance was for real and that he wouldn’t betray me, but that’s exactly what he did.

“I got out of the sport at the right time, the decade from 1990 until the EPO tests came along was one which saw substance-abuse practiced on a massive scale.

“Many of the individuals who were involved in that are still involved in the sport as team and race officials.

“There has to be a clear-out, root and branch.

“If a rider is found guilty of doping they should ban him for life and not let him back in to the sport.

“There are people out there who purport to love the sport but whose background and attitude to the problem – refusing to condemn drugs – means the problem won’t go away until we get rid of them.

“It’s ingrained in these people and they are running teams.”

What about Landis’s claim that his samples were spiked?

“You might not believe this, but I knew he was doping before the test results were even released.

“It’s the answers these guys give – they refuse to condemn drug use; Landis refused to criticize Ulrich and Basso, his answers were indirect and evasive, even when pushed.

“I like how Bradley Wiggins speaks-out against drug-taking.

“As for samples being spiked, it’s laughable – nobody believes that anymore.”

During the Tour you had some harsh words for your fellow-journalists on the subject of doping – what do you want us to do Paul?

“Don’t give them an easy ride – ask that awkward question, go down the rocky road, ask for clarification.

“I was at a certain rider’s press conference and it was just after his advisor Michele Ferrari had been banned from the sport for his involvement in doping.

“I asked how the loss of his mentor would affect his preparation; not one of literally hundreds of journalists present asked a follow-up question, the next question was about what he would do after he retired, or some-such.

“Many journalists are frightened to ask the searching questions.

“When the Cofidis affair was breaking I asked to talk to David Millar; he said he wouldn’t because he didn’t respect my work.

“I wrote that he was deeply implicated in the drugs scandal that Gaumont had gone public on, his lawyers threatened me with legal-action; shortly after that he was arrested and eventually banned for two years.

“It seems incredible to me that Millar has now announced he’s working with Luigi Cecchini; he’s telling us he’s learned his lesson and now he’s working with a man who’s has been investigated by magistrates over doping allegations.I f you want a ‘clean’ reputation you stay well clear of these people.

[Editor. Cecchini was Tyler Hamilton’s trainer at the time of the American’s infamous 2004 Vuelta positive A & B tests and positive A sample for the Olympic time trial. His name has also popped-up in the Operacion Puerto scandal.]

What do you think we have to do to have a clean sport in the future?

“There have to be tests and more tests, along the lines of the French model.

“There has to be the will at the top too; Prudhomme talks the talk, but will he walk the walk?

“I think it’s a very bad sign that he won’t release the blood samples to the Puerto investigators.

“No doubt there’s a list of legal reasons for his decision but you have to ignore that and take it on – go for it!

“The sport won’t be right until it stops treating people like me as pariahs and stops welcoming returning drugs cheats as heroes.”

Now read our interview with Paul from when we met at last year’s Tour de France.

Ed Hood and Martin Williamson
Ed and Martin, our top team! They try to do the local Time Trials, the Grand Tours and the Classics together to get the great stories written, the quality photos taken, the driving done and the wifi wrestled with.

Related Articles

Tyler Hamilton – Victim or Villain?

This interview was first published in December 2009, but in light of current events, we thought it would be interesting to re-read it and compare it's contents with what's in Tyler's book 'The Secret Race'... Now that the initial furore has died down following the shocking news of Tyler Hamilton's positive doping test, VeloVeritas thought we should hear what the man himself has to say. It took us a long time and a lot of patience, but eventually he came back to us with the answers to our questions.

The VV View: It’s Not About the Drugs – Lance Armstrong on Oprah

I didn't stay up, I must confess; but I was trawling YouTube as the clips were still being posted. The man, Lance Armstrong on Oprah, he "fessed up" - my jaw dropped, I never thought I'd see the day.

The Differences Between the US and UK versions of The Secret Race

Putting to the side for a minute the fact that Tyler lied for years about his PED use before finally coming clean and whether that means everything he says can or can't be trusted, and just reading this book with an open mind, it quickly becomes clear just how much an everyday part of pro cycling in the 1980's, 90's, and 2000's PED and illegal blood manipulation actually was. Of course, anyone with an interest in the sport already had more than an inkling that such cheating had always played a part, and fans of the sport have had to contend with scandal following scandal since forever, and particularly since the Festina affair in 1998.

The VV View – The Select Committee Question OBEs and a Knight about that Jiffy Bag

“A Team Sky spokesman said they remained fully behind their team principal (Sir David) despite the claims in the Daily Mail and his admission to the select committee on Monday that he had made mistakes.” If you’re a soccer aficionado you’ll know that if Sky was a football team Sir Dave would be out by Tuesday after a message of support like that from the Board. But word is that if Dave goes then Sky pulls the plug.

Al Hamilton – Eufemiano Fuentes and the View from Spain

Eufemiano Fuentes, Jesus Manzano, Operaciõn Puerto, Alejandro Valverde, Alberto Contador... and now Manuel Beltran. All Spanish, all hot topics - but what's the buzz in España? We turned to VeloVeritas Iberian correspondent Al Hamilton for the low down, and asked him some questions on just what the current Spanish perspective is.

The VV View: Erik Zabel Second Confession Met with UCI Silence

Erik Zabel has confessed... On the one hand we don’t think that disinterring the dead is the way forward; the French Senate mass exhumation was a pointless exercise as far as we’re concerned. But once you have a Zabelombie walking the streets you have deal with it.

At Random

The VV View: Omnium’s History, Real Professionals, and Sagan’s Ride

Honestly, we think that Jason Kenny is a great sprinter - he can go short, long and is tactically very sharp. He's not six times Olympic Champion across three disciplines because he's a dud. We also think that if he got himself off to Aguascalientes then Monsieur Pervis' 2013 world 200 and 1000 metre records of 9.347 and 56.303 respectively would be in jeopardy; not to mention Chris Hoy's 2007 standard of 24.758 for 500 metres. But how can he be a professional?

Le Tour ’11, Stage 12 – the Tour on the Tourmalet

Looking for a nice meal in Lourdes with great service? That's too bad, you'll struggle to find it! We were lucky to come across the only half-civil waiter in the town after landing in the third restaurant of the night, after being variously ignored by staff and stared at at by local idiots in the first two places we tried. Today's plan: head up to the start at Cugnaux and get a Village Depart breakfast, then drive on race route until the famous climb of the Tourmalet, where we pitched up around 3km from the top.

Dougie Young

It's with much sadness that VeloVeritas has to report the passing of another young man who's life hadn't really begun. Just days after Ben Abrahams was taken from us, Dougie Young has gone too. Rest in peace, Dougie. Sincere condolences to his friends, family and loved ones from Martin and Ed here at VeloVeritas.

Graeme Obree & Jason MacIntyre – discuss the 25 Champs postponement

It was to be the big one, the Scottish 25 Mile Time Trial Championship this Saturday, June 17th at Irvine. The British 25 Mile TT Champion, Jason MacIntyre versus the man who ran him to within 13 seconds in the Scottish 10 Mile TT Championship the previous week-former double World Pursuit Champion and World Hour Record holder, Graeme Obree (Fullarton Wheelers).

British Road Race Championships 2010 Redux

The British Road Race Championships 2010 on the 27th June was a race of attrition, but the riders started leaving via the back door very early in the race, due to the severity of the the seven-mile circuit around the Lancashire town of Barley, which was pretty much either up or down all day.

Le Tour de France 2015 – Stage 19; Saint-Jean-de-Maurienne – La Toussuire

It's fabulous being on Le Tour but it does involve hugely long days and there's always too much to do. With that in mind, to claw back a little time to get the pictures up to date, do the washing and get some proper sleep we decided to work a stage start then head for the digs.