Thursday, May 26, 2022
HomeRaceRace ReviewsLe Tour de France 2017 - Stage 5: Vittel - La planche...

Le Tour de France 2017 – Stage 5: Vittel – La planche des belles filles, 160.5km. Fabio Aru’s classy win


Mont-Saint-MichelIt may seem like scant evidence to base a major assertion upon but from what happened in the Stage One time trial – and yesterday’s first significant ascent of the race, La Planche des Belle Filles, Chris Froome (Sky & GB) has the 2017 Tour de France won barring disasters or acts of God.
Sardinia’s favourite son, Fabio Aru’s win was classy and encouraging in winning the stage; and good to see that Astana have reverted to the classic Italian champion’s jersey – that thing they had Nibali wearing wasn’t the answer.

Not that we’ll see it today, the Italian will be in polka dots thanks to the mountains points he picked up atop La Planche des Belle Filles.

Aru was a surprise in the Dauphine and that injury enforced early season rest may have done him a service, he certainly looked fresh yesterday.

He’s been on the podium in the Giro and won the Vuelta, so he has three weeks in his legs – but as we all know, ‘The Tour is the Tour.’

La planche des belles filles
Fabio Are won the stage solo. Photo©Pierre Froger/ASO

Froome has three Tour wins worth of experience behind him and his team is head and shoulders the strongest; but you have to wish Aru ‘bon chance’ – anything to prevent Sky processions.

There were few surprises on the climb yesterday, with Dan Martin (QuickStep & Birmingham), Richie Porte (BMC & Tasmania), Romain Bardet (AG2R & France) and Simon Yates (Orica & GB) all there or there abouts; Martin even getting the better of third placed Froome.

With Yates taking the white jersey as best young rider off the shoulders of French hope Pierre Latour (AG2R).

Alberto Contador (Trek & Spain), Rafa Majka (Bora & Poland), Louis Meintjes (UAE & RSA) and Nairo Quintana (Movistar & Colombia) were all a little further back than they’d like to be with Quintana’s stone face on the turbo as he warmed down telling it’s own story.

And it does look like Jakob Fuglsang’s (Denmark) Dauphine was but a purple patch – let’s hope he comes back, albeit it should be ‘all for Fabio’ at Astana after yesterday.

Kiwi, George Bennett (Lotto Jumbo) wasn’t a million miles away – remember he won the Tour of California?

La planche des belles filles
The ubiquitous Sky train in action today. Photo©Pierre Froger/ASO

OK, let’s go to the ‘elephant in the room’ – the ‘Sagasassin’ incident – or should it be ‘Cavacide’?

I popped some pictures up on my FaceBook page of the crash and have had dozens of ‘likes’/comments/’shares’ and all I can report is that the overwhelming feeling is that it was a ‘racing incident’ and there was no intent from Sagan and his expulsion was an overreaction.

And there are comments from men like Australian Six Day legend Danny Clark who knows a wee bit about sprinting.

This won’t satisfy the Cav fans – and I did get ‘pelters’ from a few Glasgow Cavanistas but the weight of opinion we’re seeing here at VeloVeritas backs up our thought from minute one that Cav went for a gap that was at best closing rapidly, at worst suicidal.

We don’t apportion ‘blame’ however; when you have some of the fastest and most highly motivated sportsmen in the world with tunnel vision for that finish line and the win – then ‘s##t happens.’

The best decision would have been to relegate Sagan to last on the stage and keep him in the race – he’s a huge loss to the Tour, as is Cav and as was Valverde.

And for all the Cav/Sag debate has anyone looked at Demare’s line in that finish sprint – straight it certainly was not.

But I forgot – he’s French.

Good to see a French stage win early however and Demare is class – no ‘duds’ ever win Milan-Sanremo.

And we have to repeat the ‘conspiracy theories’;

  • Cav knew he wasn’t going to win the stage and couldn’t round the Tour so he decked himself.
  • The ejection of Sagan is a French conspiracy to give Demare a clean run at the green jersey.

Don’t shoot the messengers, we’re only repeating them.

La planche des belles filles
The local farmers got into the TdF spirit, as usual. Photo©Pierre Froger/ASO

Next up? Stage Six, 216 kilometres, Vesoul to Troyes via a sprint at Colombey-les-Deux-Eglises home and last resting place of General Charles de Gaulle and two fourth cat. climbs.

Most likely between Demare and Kittel both of who’s teams will have to work harder now that Bora and Dimension Data have no reason to.

A demain.

La planche des belles filles
Your typical TdF wheat field image. Photo©Pierre Froger/ASO
Ed Hood
Ed Hood
Ed's been involved in cycling for over 47 years. In that time he's been a successful time triallist, a team manager, and a sponsor of several teams and clubs. He's also a respected and successful coach and during the winter months can often be found working in the cabins at the Six Days for some of the world's top riders. Ed remains a massive fan of the sport and couples his extensive contacts with an inexhaustable enthusiasm for the minutiae and the history of our sport.

Related Articles

Le Tour de France 2007 – Day 1: Stage 12, Montpellier – Castres

Bonjour! It's that time - there's only one game in town and it's called, 'Le Tour'. Ken Livingston's ego trip and the stages Viktor calls; "watchin' paint dry!" are behind us, so are the Alps. Tomorrow it's the first time trial then it's the Pyrennes; sprinter and transition stages; the final tt and Paris. God-willing, we'll be there all the way. We arrived at Perpignan around 6.00, local time, it's nearly 9.00 now and we've still got our accreditation to collect at Castres. Wheels for the trip, is a Renault Clio, the air-con and stereo and iPod work, that's all you need really.

Le Tour de France 2015 – Stage 19; Saint-Jean-de-Maurienne – La Toussuire

It's fabulous being on Le Tour but it does involve hugely long days and there's always too much to do. With that in mind, to claw back a little time to get the pictures up to date, do the washing and get some proper sleep we decided to work a stage start then head for the digs.

Le Tour de France 2012 – Stage 12: Saint-Jean-de-Maurienne – Annonay Davézieux, 220 km.

What a day; when we heard Millar was in the break, we knew he was definitely capable of beating three of his companions - Gautier was the only one we didn't know about. But when we saw him, we knew he'd win - it was there in his eyes, if you knew what you were looking at.

Le Tour de France 2007 – Day 9: Stage 19, Cognac – Angoulême

I forgot to say last night, for the first time in this Tour, I got a prediction right. I chose Casar out of the four man break, you could see it in his eyes, he wanted it more than any of the others. There's a great picture of him on the front cover of L'Equipe today - it's all there in his face, determination and pride; "maybe the other French guys can't win a stage, but I sure as hell can!" Cafè au lait (have you noticed that Mertin has shown me how to get accents above the letters now?) and a Cognac, nine euros!?! "Eef you cannot steeff les touristes, then oo' can you steeff, hien?" Still, it was a good coffee, a grande measure of cognac and the toilets were free of Lasa Fever.

Le Tour de France 2014 – Second Rest Day; Catching up with Jack Bauer

Jack Bauer; tall, dark, slim, handsome, polite, grounded, friendly - it would have been so nice to add 'Tour de France stage winner' to that description. Dave and I were holed up in a nice old bar/restaurant attached to a genteel hotel in Carcassonne watching the finale of Stage 15 and willing the big man from the land of the long white cloud to cross that line first.

Daryl Impey – “You have to make sacrifices for the bigger picture”

Daryl Impey is the man who suffered a horrific crash in the final metres of the Presidential Tour of Turkey in 2009, with the yellow jersey on his back - when Theo Boss decided that the South African might like to make a close inspection of the crash barriers.

At Random

Il Giro d’Italia 2014 – Stage 6; Sassano – Monte Cassino, 247 km. The Aussies Push On

Already the ‘Forum Sitters’ are telling us that it was ‘unsporting’ of Evans and Matthews to take advantage of the mayhem which again reigned on the slopes of Cassino as two simultaneous crashes brought down droves of riders when they braked into a roundabout and left a group of eight clear at the front at the very foot of the ascent to the Abbey. Evans and Matthews both had two team mates with them who rode themselves into the ground to build an advantage.

Rory McGuire – National Trophy Cyclo-Cross Series Round 4 Winner

Cameron Mason isn’t the only Scot, ‘on the up’ in the washing powder-challenging world of cyclo-cross; 19 year-old Perth man, Rory McGuire (Wheelbase-CabTech Castelli) recently took round four of the National Trophy Cyclo-cross Series near Sunderland.

Paul Sherwen

‘Well Phil,’ the words that we all remember so well, used by Paul Sherwen when he was about to put co-commentator Phil Liggett right about something during one of the hundreds of Tour de France stages the pair covered for TV networks from England to Australia via the USA. Sadly, we’ll hear that catch phrase no more, the 62 year-old Briton having passed away in his sleep at his home in Kampala in his adopted nation of Uganda on Sunday.

Commonwealth Games 2014 – Time Trial, Elite Women, Villumsen for New Zealand

Many times present on a major championship podium but never on the top step, New Zealand's Linda Villumsen finally claimed her first gold medal today with a six second margin over former World Champion at the discipline Emma Pooley (England), riding her last time trial as a pro cyclist. The bronze medal went to the German-born professional with Orica-AIS Katrin Garfoot, riding for Australia.

Le Tour de France 2013 – Stage 15: Givors > Mont Ventoux, 242km. Froome Stamps.

It was a long day for VeloVeritas, yesterday. But it was a cracker – positioned 800 metres from the line on Mont Ventoux, we were there from when Froome spun past like a madman on rollers until Jonathan Hivert ground past us, oh so painfully, some 50 minutes later.

Le Tour de France 2012 – First Rest Day

Bonjour! VeloVeritas joins le Tour. The hotel is the Formule 1, Viry, with a wonderful view of a pile of tyres – it’s a glamorous life. But we’re not complaining. Easyjet, Edinburgh to Geneva wasn’t too bad, finding the car hire was a bit of a magical mystery tour but we were soon headed for Mâcon, our credentials and the Saxo Bank-Tinkoff Bank hotel.