Monday, December 6, 2021
HomeRaceRace ReviewsLe Tour de France 2017 - Stage 5: Vittel - La planche...

Le Tour de France 2017 – Stage 5: Vittel – La planche des belles filles, 160.5km. Fabio Aru’s classy win


Mont-Saint-MichelIt may seem like scant evidence to base a major assertion upon but from what happened in the Stage One time trial – and yesterday’s first significant ascent of the race, La Planche des Belle Filles, Chris Froome (Sky & GB) has the 2017 Tour de France won barring disasters or acts of God.
Sardinia’s favourite son, Fabio Aru’s win was classy and encouraging in winning the stage; and good to see that Astana have reverted to the classic Italian champion’s jersey – that thing they had Nibali wearing wasn’t the answer.

Not that we’ll see it today, the Italian will be in polka dots thanks to the mountains points he picked up atop La Planche des Belle Filles.

Aru was a surprise in the Dauphine and that injury enforced early season rest may have done him a service, he certainly looked fresh yesterday.

He’s been on the podium in the Giro and won the Vuelta, so he has three weeks in his legs – but as we all know, ‘The Tour is the Tour.’

La planche des belles filles
Fabio Are won the stage solo. Photo©Pierre Froger/ASO

Froome has three Tour wins worth of experience behind him and his team is head and shoulders the strongest; but you have to wish Aru ‘bon chance’ – anything to prevent Sky processions.

There were few surprises on the climb yesterday, with Dan Martin (QuickStep & Birmingham), Richie Porte (BMC & Tasmania), Romain Bardet (AG2R & France) and Simon Yates (Orica & GB) all there or there abouts; Martin even getting the better of third placed Froome.

With Yates taking the white jersey as best young rider off the shoulders of French hope Pierre Latour (AG2R).

Alberto Contador (Trek & Spain), Rafa Majka (Bora & Poland), Louis Meintjes (UAE & RSA) and Nairo Quintana (Movistar & Colombia) were all a little further back than they’d like to be with Quintana’s stone face on the turbo as he warmed down telling it’s own story.

And it does look like Jakob Fuglsang’s (Denmark) Dauphine was but a purple patch – let’s hope he comes back, albeit it should be ‘all for Fabio’ at Astana after yesterday.

Kiwi, George Bennett (Lotto Jumbo) wasn’t a million miles away – remember he won the Tour of California?

La planche des belles filles
The ubiquitous Sky train in action today. Photo©Pierre Froger/ASO

OK, let’s go to the ‘elephant in the room’ – the ‘Sagasassin’ incident – or should it be ‘Cavacide’?

I popped some pictures up on my FaceBook page of the crash and have had dozens of ‘likes’/comments/’shares’ and all I can report is that the overwhelming feeling is that it was a ‘racing incident’ and there was no intent from Sagan and his expulsion was an overreaction.

And there are comments from men like Australian Six Day legend Danny Clark who knows a wee bit about sprinting.

This won’t satisfy the Cav fans – and I did get ‘pelters’ from a few Glasgow Cavanistas but the weight of opinion we’re seeing here at VeloVeritas backs up our thought from minute one that Cav went for a gap that was at best closing rapidly, at worst suicidal.

We don’t apportion ‘blame’ however; when you have some of the fastest and most highly motivated sportsmen in the world with tunnel vision for that finish line and the win – then ‘s##t happens.’

The best decision would have been to relegate Sagan to last on the stage and keep him in the race – he’s a huge loss to the Tour, as is Cav and as was Valverde.

And for all the Cav/Sag debate has anyone looked at Demare’s line in that finish sprint – straight it certainly was not.

But I forgot – he’s French.

Good to see a French stage win early however and Demare is class – no ‘duds’ ever win Milan-Sanremo.

And we have to repeat the ‘conspiracy theories’;

  • Cav knew he wasn’t going to win the stage and couldn’t round the Tour so he decked himself.
  • The ejection of Sagan is a French conspiracy to give Demare a clean run at the green jersey.

Don’t shoot the messengers, we’re only repeating them.

La planche des belles filles
The local farmers got into the TdF spirit, as usual. Photo©Pierre Froger/ASO

Next up? Stage Six, 216 kilometres, Vesoul to Troyes via a sprint at Colombey-les-Deux-Eglises home and last resting place of General Charles de Gaulle and two fourth cat. climbs.

Most likely between Demare and Kittel both of who’s teams will have to work harder now that Bora and Dimension Data have no reason to.

A demain.

La planche des belles filles
Your typical TdF wheat field image. Photo©Pierre Froger/ASO
Ed Hood
Ed's been involved in cycling for over 45 years. In that time he's been a successful time triallist, team manager, and sponsor of several teams and clubs. He's also a respected and successful coach, and during the winter months can often be found working in the cabins at the Six Days. Ed remains a massive fan of the sport and couples his extensive contacts with an inexhaustable enthusiasm for the minutiae and the history of our sport.

Related Articles

Le Tour de France 2007 – Day 8: Stage 18, Cahors – Angoulême

It took a wee while to find the hotel last night in Cahors, but it was worth it. It's an old farm which has been converted to a hotel, complete with swimming pool; it's quite the idylic spot. We are sharing hotels with an American cycle tour party, we've has done a deal with them - ads on the site in exchange for hotel rooms for us on the Tour. Three of the party were sitting near us at breakfast, this morning, oldest guy to other two; "D'you think Armstrong was a doper?" ...Silence!

Le Tour de France 2008 – Day 3: Rest Day

Ciao! It was gone midnight when we hit the hay, last night. There was no thought of food, just sleep, it seemed to take an age to get off the mountain at Pratto and get to our digs at Racconigi - maybe it was just because we were so tired. Breakfast was chronic, stale bread, no cheese, no ham and everything else in polythene wrappers. First mission of the day was to meet Stuey O'Grady at the CSC press conference. He's a buddy of Martin's pal, Pete Jacques.

Final Shot (Preview: TDF 2012 St 17)

Today is the stage that I have been looking forward to the most since I had a proper look at the various stage profiles back in early June. It is a genuine belter! The back end of the race includes an Hors Categorie climb immediately followed by a First Categorie climb.

Perfect Storm of Crap: TdF 2010 Stage 2 (mini LBL)

Perfect Storm of Crap! All talk of the Mock aside, holy crap. What a day. Yesterday’s stage was dubbed a mini Liege-Bastogne-Liege as it covered a segment of the same course as that particular race. For those not in the know, LBL is one of the major Spring Classics on the calendar. It’s a tough race with lots of short, sharp hills on very small old roads.

Le Tour de France 2017 – Stage 19: Embrun – Salon-de-Provence, 222.5km. Edvald Boasson-Hagen at last!

To paraphrase the late, great Donna Summer; ‘they work hard for the money.’ Those Sky boys. Perhaps Henao had a few mountain days where Sir David and Le Chien Froomey didn’t think the Columbian did enough graft – he made up for it on Stage 19 though, riding tempo remorselessly on the front of the peloton. Spectacular? No. Damn hard work? For sure.

Le Tour de France 2016 – Stage 9; Vielha Val d’Aran – Andorre Arcalis. Dumoulin Solos to Victory

Tom Dumoulin tests to solo glory in Andorra; Pinot goes poids; Froome consolidates jaune; Porte confuses; Martin rises to another level; Yates confirms; Aru and Tejay slide whilst Quintana waits – but it’s over for Alberto. But all that said - no real changes from yesterday and the Bigs only race the last few kilometres...

At Random

Llewellyn Kinch – Two Wins from 13 Starts in Belgian Kermises

Our man with his finger on the Flanders pulse, Vik, first tipped us off about this gentleman at the end of the 2011 season. Llewellyn Kinch was getting up there on the Belgian results websites and onto Vik’s radar. Here are the background questions we asked, from the end of the 2011 season.

Humbie Mountain Time Trial 2010

Stuart Moran (Perth United) made it a successful trip to East Lothian for the Humbie Mountain Time Trial 2010 today, taking the win over a hard two-lap circuit by 20 seconds.

Tom England – u16 French Champion in the Madison

For the first time in many a year VeloVeritas didn’t make it down to Grenoble for the Four Days on the battle scarred boards of the winter track where Post, Merckx, Sercu, Clark, Moser and Thevent have all lifted the laurels. How I miss Bar Clemenceau, Pizza Natalie and the wee bakers where the baker always give me extra croissants ‘for luck.’ ‘New Wave’ French strong men and World Madison Champions Morgan Kneisky and Vivien Brisse took the honours from tough Spaniards Muntaner & Torres with Iljo Keisse limbering up for Gent in third spot with countryman De Buyst.

Saunier Duval Team Launch 2008 – Day 1

The Saunier Duval Team Launch 2008 squad changed a little from last season - the team is made up of 26 riders, and one of its distinctive features will be it's youth: there will be no less than nine men under 24 years of age, and thus the team will be the second youngest in the ProTour peloton. The second distinctive feature of the team this season will be improved training: two personal trainers have been hired: Sergio Gelati, who worked with the team in 2007.

Le Tour de France 2014 – Stage 9; Gérardmer – Mulhouse, 166 km. Tony Martin Solo

Patrick Lefevre said today it was one of the greatest performances he has ever seen; Tony Martin fought for more than an hour to establish a gap of 30 seconds and then go away from the second group of 25 riders with the whole Europcar team trying to get him back. Remember that Lefevre has been one of the most respected managers in the sport for two decades and isn’t prone to throwing praise around.

Maurice Laing – Scottish Star of the 70’s had a Short but Scintillating Career

Maurice Laing won the Scottish school boy road race and time trial championships, made the podium of the junior and senior road race championships; won the Davie Bell, Sam Robinson and Trophy Pernod; rode the Milk Race and performed with distinction in France.